The story
The Carmelite order began among hermits on Mount Carmel in the Holy Land. A cherished tradition holds that Our Lady appeared to the English Carmelite St. Simon Stock on July 16, 1251, and gave him the brown scapular, with the promise of salvation for those who die wearing it.
History and debate
The historical record of this vision is thin. The first known reference comes from the late 14th century, more than a hundred years later, and the great Carmelite authors of that century do not mention it. Historians since the early 20th century have considered the letter behind the 1251 date a forgery published by John Cheron. Some Catholic writers still defend the tradition, and the devotion itself does not depend on the date.
Visiting today
There is no single shrine. Stella Maris on Mount Carmel in Haifa and The Friars at Aylesford in England are the places most linked to the tradition, and the scapular is worn worldwide.
Sources
Last reviewed: November 1, 2026

